Tracking down prehistoric remains across the expansive world of Red Dead Redemption 2 represents one of the most rewarding collectible hunts for completionists. Players unlock this extensive quest after meeting Deborah MacGuiness, an amateur paleontologist located southeast of Horseshoe Overlook in the Heartlands. Finding all 30 fossilized specimens requires careful exploration across multiple states, taking players from lush forests to arid desert canyons.
Starting the A Test of Faith Quest
Before embarking on the hunt, players must initiate the A Test of Faith stranger mission to activate the collectible log. Speaking with Deborah MacGuiness provides the initial context and prompts Arthur or John to mail discovered coordinates from any post office. Sending progress updates unlocks useful rewards, culminating in a special invitation once all locations are recorded.
Finding the first few sites near New Hanover gives players a solid grasp of how these specimens blend into the environment. Eagle Eye is an essential tool during exploration, as it highlights the subtle glow of buried fossils hidden among rock walls or grassy hillsides.
Navigating the Northern and Eastern Regions
A significant portion of the fossil sites can be found across Ambarino, New Hanover, and Lemoyne. In the Heartlands, bone locations are often tucked away near landmark structures like the old oil derrick or dry riverbeds. Moving toward Cumberland Forest and the Grizzlies requires checking steep cliff edges and rocky plateaus overlooking major rivers.
Lush woodland regions like Roanoke Ridge also hide several remains along intermediate cliff ledges near the Kamassa River. Exploring these diverse terrains rewards players with distinct scenery while systematically reducing the remaining checklist count.
Exploring West Elizabeth and New Austin
As the journey progresses west, player pathing moves through Big Valley and the areas surrounding Mount Shann. Hidden cave networks and high mountain slopes in West Elizabeth contain notable bone sites that require careful foot navigation. Finding these remote spots often leads to breathtaking views of the wilderness below.
The remaining collectible sites lie across New Austin, situated near Tumbleweed, Fort Mercer, and Gaptooth Ridge. Due to story boundaries early in the game, visiting these desert locations typically occurs during later chapters. Traversing the arid canyons of Cholla Springs and Rio Bravo completes the collection map.
Claiming Your Final Quest Rewards
After mailing the final set of coordinates, players must wait for a response letter at the local post office. Reading the invitation places a quest marker near Cumberland Forest, leading back to Deborah MacGuiness's workshop.
A unique cutscene plays upon arrival, revealing the fully reconstructed fossil creation. As a final reward for completing the lengthy quest, players receive the unique Jawbone Knife collectible to add to their weapon wheel.